Agents Like Snowden Prone to Irrational Decision Making

ITHACA, N.Y. U.S. intelligence agents like the embattled Edward Snowden are more prone to irrational inconsistencies in decision making when compared to college students and post-college adults. Thats according a new Cornell University study to be published in an upcoming issue of the journal Psychological Science.

The study found intelligence agents exhibited larger biases on 30 gain-loss framing decisions, and were also more confident in those decisions. Thirty-six agents were recruited for the study from an anonymous federal agency, and were presented with scenarios such as:

- The U.S. is preparing for the outbreak of an unusual disease, which is expected to kill 600 people. Do you: Save 200 people for sure, or choose the option with 1/3 probability that 600 will be saved and a 2/3 probability no one will be saved?

- In the same scenario, do you pick the option where 400 will surely die, or instead a 2/3 probability that all 600 will die and a 1/3 probability no one dies?

The results showed agents treated equivalent outcomes differently based on superficial wording. They were more willing than college students to take risks with human lives when outcomes were framed as losses.

These results shed light on the decision-making mechanisms of intelligence agents who identify and mitigate risks to national security, said Valerie Reyna, Cornell professor of human development and psychology, and lead author of the study. Like some other laboratory gambling tasks, framing effects have been shown to predict real-world behavior, Reyna added.

Reyna also said these results suggest that meaning and context play a larger role in risky decision-making as experts gain experience. That experience can enhance performance, but also has predictable pitfalls.

More from the journal Psychological Science:
http://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/news/were-only-human/spooky-judgments-how-spies-think-about-danger.html

Contact Syl Kacapyr for information about Cornell's TV and radio studios.

More information you can also find on website: College Credit

News source: NewsWise

Source:
Agents Like Snowden Prone to Irrational Decision Making

See also:

National Association of Social Workers Press and Oxford University Press Partner Up to Publish Online the Indispensible Encyclopedia of Social Work
EMBARGOED UNTIL JULY 8, 2013National Association of Social Workers Press & Oxford University Press Partner Up to Publish Online the Indispensable Encyclopedia of Social WorkOxford University Press...

Hendren Group Comments on Tesla & Musk Early Repayment
May 23, 2013 - Hendren Group, the international global investment company based in Tokyo, Japan, have recently issued a statement to their investors outlining the various advantages of including Tesla...

PLAYTIME Unveils HD/3D Game Console, Expands Play from Toddlers to Tween-agers
PLAYTIME, the global leader in soft playground equipment for indoor, outdoor and water play, has unveiled a video game console that expands its market reach as well as its clients ability to entertain...